At a asset deal specific VAT rules apply that are fundamentally different from a share deal. In an asset deal, individual business assets are transferred, making VAT payable on most assets. The VAT treatment depends on the type of assets, the structure of the transaction and whether there is a transfer of a generality of assets. Professional guidance prevents costly mistakes in complex M&A-transactions.
What is the difference between an asset deal and a share deal for VAT purposes?
At a asset deal individual business assets are transferred and VAT is due on most assets. In a share deal, shares are sold, which is VAT-exempt as a financial service. This fundamental difference determines the tax structure of the entire transaction.
An asset deal means transfer of specific assets, such as machinery, inventory, goodwill and contracts. Each transfer constitutes a separate VAT supply at the applicable rate. The seller invoices VAT to the buyer, unless specific exemptions apply.
A share deal involves the sale of shares in the target company. This transaction falls under the VAT exemption for financial services. The buyer indirectly acquires the assets through the shareholding, with no direct VAT impact at the asset level.
Choosing between the two structures has far-reaching implications for overall transaction costs and cash flow. Asset deals can involve substantial VAT charges, while share deals can be more tax-efficient but introduce other legal complexities.
What VAT rules apply when transferring assets in an asset deal?
Tangible fixed assets, such as machinery and inventory, are taxed at 21% VAT. Intangible assets, including software, patents and goodwill, are also subject to the high rate. Inventories are taxed in accordance with their normal VAT treatment in the seller's business.
VAT treatment varies by asset category. Commercial buildings less than two years old are taxed at 21%, while older buildings may qualify for exemption. Vehicles, computers and furniture fall under the high rate by default, with no exceptions.
Contractual rights and customer files are treated as intangible assets for tax purposes. Their transfer triggers VAT, whether as a separate consideration or as part of an overall package. Licences and intellectual property follow the same system.
Working capital, such as debtors and creditors, has no direct VAT impact on transfer. The underlying receivables and payables retain their original VAT character. Cash and cash equivalents are obviously VAT-free on transfer.
When does the VAT exemption for transfer of a universality of goods apply?
The VAT exemption applies when a independent industry is transferred that can be continued immediately by the buyer. It is required that all essential assets for the business are transferred, including staff, customer base and operational resources. The transfer must involve a functioning unit.
Three cumulative conditions determine the application. The transferred entity must be able to operate independently without additional investment by the buyer. All assets necessary to operate the business must be included. The buyer must be able to continue operations immediately without fundamental adjustments.
Practical pitfalls arise with partial acquisitions or cherry picking of assets. Transfer of only machinery, without staff or customer base, does not qualify for exemption. The same applies to transfer of only goodwill, without operational assets.
Interpretation requires careful analysis of the specific circumstances. Sector-specific factors, such as regulatory licensing, specialised knowledge and market positioning, influence the assessment. Documentation of business continuity is crucial for legal certainty.
How does VAT reverse charge work in asset deals between entrepreneurs?
In B2B asset transactions VAT reverse charge, making the buyer liable for VAT instead of the seller. The seller invoices exclusive of VAT and explicitly mentions the reverse charge mechanism. The buyer calculates and pays the VAT via its own return.
The reverse charge mechanism requires both parties to be VAT entrepreneurs. The seller must mention the reverse charge on the invoice with the text “VAT transferred to the buyer”. The buyer accounts for the VAT as both due and input tax in the same return period.
Administrative obligations vary from one party to another. The seller records turnover excluding VAT and keeps documentation of the buyer's entrepreneurial status. The buyer administers the VAT deflection and ensures correct processing in its accounts.
The cash flow impact is neutral when the buyer is fully deductible. With limited deductibility, a final VAT charge arises for the non-deductible part. This factor can affect the negotiating position and pricing.
What VAT aspects should you check during due diligence of an asset deal?
Check the historical VAT positions of the target company, including ongoing proceedings and disputes with the tax authorities. Analyse the VAT treatment of various asset flows and verify the accuracy of rates and exemptions applied over the past years.
Ongoing VAT procedures represent potential hidden burdens. Investigate outstanding objections, appeals and audits by the tax authorities. Assess the likelihood of retrospective levies and the potential impact on transaction structure and pricing.
Future VAT liabilities require specific attention. Analyse the purchaser's deductibility for the assets to be acquired. Check whether changes in use or destination result in VAT adjustments or revisions to previously deducted VAT.
Documentation of VAT processing should be complete and accurate. Verify invoicing, returns and correspondence with the tax authorities. Identify deviations from standard practice that may introduce risks for the buyer after acquisition.
What are the consequences of incorrect VAT treatment in an asset transaction?
Incorrect VAT treatment leads to surcharges including fines, which can amount to up to 100% of VAT due. The Inland Revenue can look back five years and levies interest on the period from when the debt was incurred. Both transaction parties can be held liable.
Post-tax risks vary depending on the nature of the error. Administrative errors result in retrospective taxation plus a limited fine. Deliberate evasion results in maximum fines and possible criminal prosecution. The burden of proof for good faith lies with the taxpayer.
Correction options exist through voluntary correction within the declaration period. After this deadline, correction is only possible through objection and appeal procedures. Proactive correction reduces the penalty risk, but does not eliminate the after-tax penalty itself.
Preventive measures include thorough tax due diligence and professional guidance during the transaction. Contractual agreements on VAT risks and guarantees provide protection against unforeseen burdens. In complex fusion or acquisition transactions specialist tax advice is indispensable for optimal structuring and risk management. For professional support on your transaction, you can contact with us.
Link copied!
